Digital Ecosystems and the Right to Refuse Technology

D. S. Denisov

Abstract


The article considers the issue of digitalization of political processes in the context of digital ecosystems. The concept of a digital ecosystem and related social phenomena are investigated. The potential influences of digital ecosystems on particular social institutions are assessed. It is argued that one of the consequences of the digital transformation may be the development of trends for social exclusion of those categories of the population, who, for certain reasons, are unwilling or unable to use digital technologies. As a legal and ethical guarantee to ensure equal and non-discriminatory participation in social processes, it is proposed to establish by law the institution of the right not to interact with the state and society digitally. Based on the analysis of academic sources, the arguments of many researchers in favor of the development of this legal institution are presented. It is concluded that there is a need to ensure equal and non-discriminatory access for people to participate in fundamental social processes, excluding the actual loss of rights (including participation in government) of an entire category of citizens.

Full Text:

PDF (Russian)

References


Tsifrovaya transformatsiya otraslei: startovie usloviya i prioriteti [Digital transformation of industries: start-up conditions and priorities]: report to the XXII April International Scientific Conference on Economic and Social Development, Moscow, April 13-30, 2021 / G.I. Abdrakhmanova, K.B. Bikhovskii, N.N. Veselitskaya, K.O. Vishnevskii, L.M. Gokhberg et al.; lead auth. P.B. Rudnik; ed. by L.M. Gokhberg, P.B. Rudnik, K.O. Vishnevskii, T.S. Zinina; National Research University Higher School of Economics. Moscow, Higher School for Economics' Publishing House, 2021. 239 p.

Glava Minkomsvyazi Maksut Shadaev obsudil tsifrovuyu ekosistemu gosudarstva s direktorami IT-kompanii na konferentsii TAdviser [Maksut Shadayev, Head of the Ministry of Digital Development, Communications and Mass Media of the Russian Federation, discussed the digital ecosystem of the state with the directors of IT companies at the TAdviser conference] URL: www.tadviser.ru/index.php/Статья:Цифровая_экосистема_государства (date of request: 02.02.2023).

Gosudarstvo kak platforma: Lyudi i tekhnologii [The State as a Platform: People and Technology] / ed. by M.S. Shklyaruk. Moscow, RANEPA, 2019. 111 p.

Frolov A.A., Sokolov A.V., Yegorov D.V. Klyuchevie kharakteristiki tsifrovikh ekosistem v politike [The Key Characteristics of Digital Ecosystems in Policy] // Upravlencheskoe konsultirovanie. 2023. № 2. P. 46–55.

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (text in Russian). Proclaimed by the United Nations General Assembly in Paris on 10 December 1948 (General Assembly resolution 217 A). URL: https://www.un.org/ru/documents/decl_conv/declarations/declhr.shtml (date of request: 13.03.2023).

Filatova O.G., Chugunov A.V. Razvitie ekosistemi elektronnogo uchastiya v Rossii v nachale 2020-kh: rol sotsialnikh media i tsentrov upravleniya regionami [Development of the e-participation ecosystem in Russia in the early 2020’s: the role of social media and regional management centers] // Politicheskaya ekspertiza: POLITEKS. 2022. № 2. P. 120-137.

Moore J. Predators and Prey: а New Ecology of Competition // Harvard Business Review. 1993. Vol. 71, № 3. P. 75-86.

Tansley A.G. The Use and Abuse of Vegetational Concepts and Terms // Ecology. 1935. Vol. 16, № 3. P. 284-307.

Global Top 100 companies by market capitalization (2023). URL: https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/audit-services/publications/top100/pwc-global-top-100-companies-2023.pdf (date of request: 16.04.2023).

Ekosistemi: podkhodi k regulirovaniyu. Doklad dlya obshchestvennikh konsultatsii [Ecosystems: Approaches to Regulation. Public consultation report] // The Central Bank of the Russian Federation. 2021. URL: http://www.cbr.ru/content/document/file/119960/consultation_paper_02042021.pdf (date of request: 13.03.2023).

Kontseptsiya obshchego regulirovaniya deyatelnosti grupp kompanii, razvivayushchikh razlichnie tsifrovie servisi na baze odnoi «ekosistemi» [The concept of general regulation of the activities of groups of companies developing various digital services based on one “ecosystem”] // The Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation. 2021. URL: https://www.economy.gov.ru/material/file/cb29a7d08290120645a871be41599850/koncepciya_21052021.pdf (date of request: 07.03.2023).

Aktualnie voprosi regulirovaniya ekosistem [Current issues in ecosystem regulation] // Report of the Center for Strategic Research Foundation. 2021. URL: http://www.lccp.econ.msu.ru/sadm_files/Доклад%20Экосистемы_длинная%20версия%20(ЦСР).pdf (date of request: 15.02.2023).

Evolyutsiya ekosistem v Rossii: evolyutsiya, tipologiya, podkhodi k regulirovaniyu [Evolution of ecosystems in Russia: evolution, typology, regulatory approaches] // The Ye. T. Gaidar Institute for Economic Policy. 2022. URL: https://www.iep.ru/files/ecosystems_results-2022.pdf; https://www.iep.ru/files/news/Issledovanie_jekosistem_Otchet.pdf (date of request: 22.02.2023).

Tsifrovaya ekonomika: globalnie trendi i praktika rossiiskogo biznesa [Digital Economy: Global Trends and Practices in Russian Business] / ed. by D.S. Medovnikov. HSE, 2017. 121 p. URL: https://imi.hse.ru/pr2017_1 (date of request: 18.02.2023).

Chto takoe tsifrovaya ekonomika? Trendi, kompetentsii, izmerenie [What is the digital economy? Trends, competencies, measurement]: report to the XX April International Scientific Conference on Economic and Social Development, Moscow, April 9–12, 2019 / G.I. Abdrakhmanova, K.O. Vishnevskii, L.M. Gokhberg et al.; ed. by L.M. Gokhberg; National Research University Higher School of Economics. — Moscow, Higher School for Economics' Publishing House, 2019. — 82 p.

GOST R 33.505-2003. Edinii rossiiskii strakhovoi fond dokumentatsii. Poryadok sozdaniya strakhovogo fonda dokumentatsii, yavlyayushcheisya natsionalnim nauchnim, kulturnim i istoricheskim naslediem [GOST R 33.505-2003. Unified Russian insurance fund documentation. Establishment of an insurance fund for documentation that is a national scientific, cultural and historical heritage (The State Standard of Russian Federation)]: approved by the Federal Technical Regulation and Metrology Agency (Rosstandart) decree N 255-st of July 29, 2003. URL: https://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=OTN&n=9052#DqdAmwTIhHBqL7E82 (date of request: 04.04.2023). Access from the legal database “Consultant Plus”. Access mode: for registered users.

Volos A.A., Ivanov A.A. Tsifrovizatsiya i Konstitutsiya [Digitalization and the Constitution] // Zakon. 2022. № 12. URL: https://login.consultant.ru/link/?req=doc&base=CJI&n=147811 (date of request: 17.03.2023). Access from the legal database “Consultant Plus”. Access mode: for registered users.

Gritsenko E.V. Pravo na khoroshee upravlenie v usloviyakh tsifrovoi transformatsii [The Right to Good Governance in the Context of Digital Transformation] // Sravnitelnoe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2022. № 4. URL: https://login.consultant.ru/link/?req=doc&base=CJI&n=144354&dst=100004 (date of request: 17.03.2023). Access from the legal database “Consultant Plus”. Access mode: for registered users.

Ukaz mera Moskvi N 47-UM ot 21.04.2020 «O vnesenii izmenenii v ukazi Mera Moskvi ot 5 marta 2020 g. N 12-UM i ot 11 aprelya 2020 g. N 43-UM» [Decree of the Mayor of Moscow of April 21, 2020 N 47-UM “On the amendment of the decrees of the Mayor of Moscow of March 5, 2020 N 12-UM and of April 11, 2020 N 43-UM”]. URL: https://www.mos.ru/authority/documents/doc/43758220 (date of request: 08.02.2023).

Klishas zayavil ob otsutstvii u Sobyanina prava na vvod massovikh ogranichenii [Klishas declared that Sobyanin had no right to impose mass restrictions] URL: https://www.rbc.ru/society/29/03/2020/5e80f0a69a794757bbe913eb (date of request: 08.02.2023).

Ukaz mera Moskvi N 13-UM ot 03.03.2022 «O vnesenii izmenenii v ukaz Mera Moskvi ot 8 iyunya 2020 g. N 68-UM» [Decree of the Mayor of Moscow of March 3, 2022 N 13-UM “On the amendment of the decree of the Mayor of Moscow of June 8, 2020 N 68 UM”]. URL: https://www.mos.ru/authority/documents/doc/48464220 (date of request: 08.02.2023).

QR-kodi v rossiiskikh regionakh [QR-codes in Russian regions]. URL: https://ria.ru/20220120/qr-kody-1768550435.html (date of request: 08.02.2023).

Alebastrova I., Rasskazova N., Savelev A., Tsigankov D., Ostapets I., Pashin S., Tai Yu., Ribalov A., Brizgalin A. Pravovie itogi – 2020 [The legal annual results of 2020] // Zakon. 2021. № 1. P. 19-40.

Etika i «tsifra»: ot problem k resheniyam [Ethics and "digit": from problems to solutions] / ed. by Ye.G. Potapova, M.S. Shklyaruk. Moscow, RANEPA, 2021. 184 p.

Ranchordás S. The Digitization of Government and Digital Exclusion: Setting the Scene // Law, Governance and Technology Series. 2022. Vol. 49. P. 125-148.

Tsifrovaya transformatsiya i zashchita prav grazhdan. Doklad Soveta pri Prezidente Rossiiskoi Federatsii po razvitiyu grazhdanskogo obshchestva i pravam cheloveka [Digital transformation and protection of citizens' rights. Report of the Presidential Council for the Development of Civil Society and Human Rights]. Moscow, 2021. URL: http://www.president-sovet.ru/docs/doclad_SPCh.docx?ysclid=lkd0487nq5493183387 (date of request: 17.03.2023).

Proekt kontseptsii obespecheniya zashchiti prav i svobod cheloveka i grazhdanina v tsifrovom prostranstve Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Draft concept of ensuring the protection of human and civil rights and freedoms in the digital space of the Russian Federation] URL: https://rocit.ru/uploads/4f68dc0a2487678a7675ad7589280277050b4004.docx.?t=1639585614 (date of request: 17.03.2023).

Doklad o deyatelnosti Upolnomochennogo po pravam cheloveka v Rossiiskoi Federatsii za 2022 god [Report on the activities of the Ombudsman in the Russian Federation for 2022] URL: https://ombudsmanrf.org/storage/74a0484f-7d5a-4fe4-883d-a1b5ba1dd5f8/mediateca/doclad-2022.pdf (date of request: 20.03.2023).

Naumov V.B. Otkaz ot tsifrovikh tekhnologii: absurd ili novoe pravo cheloveka i grazhdanina [Rejection of digital technologies: an absurdity or a new human and civil right] // 4-th Bachilovskie chteniya: materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference / ed. by T.A. Polyakova, A.V. Minbaleev, V.B. Naumov. Moscow, Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 2022. P. 78-84.

Internet shutdowns: trends, causes, legal implications and impacts on a range of human rights. Report of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (text in Russian). 13 May 2022. URL: https://undocs.org/A/HRC/50/55 (date of request: 11.02.2023).

Polyakova T.A., Naumov V.B., Minbaleev A.V. Trust in the law during the digital transformation // State and Law. № 11. 2022. P. 139-147.

Schwab K. Chetvertaya promishlennaya revolyutsiya (text in Russian) [The Fourth Industrial Revolution]. Eksmo, 2016. 208 p.

Tsifrovizatsiya i prava cheloveka: ambivalentnii kharakter [Digitalization and human rights: ambivalent nature]. Centre for Studies of Civil Society and the Nonprofit Sector National Research University Higher School of Economics (HSE). Moscow, 2021. URL: https://grans.hse.ru/mirror/pubs/share/517746658.pdf (date of request: 14.03.2023).


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Abava  Кибербезопасность MoNeTec 2024

ISSN: 2307-8162