Rules for compiling and subtracting matrixes of values for two groups of indicators for assessing the quality of big technical systems

K.Z. Bilyatdinov, Е.А. Krivchun


The article presents a basic formula and a universal table for development of structure functional models of big technical systems. The method takes into account priorities of performed functions and substructures of big technical systems, also, maximum and minimum values of basic indices of technical systems. In order to compare “ideal” and real models it is recommended to use a corresponding subtraction of matrixes of quality indices. For this purpose, matrixes of indices are sorted into two groups: the one, where the minimum value of an index is considered the best, and another, where the maximum value is considered the best. The results of matrixes subtraction make a basis for the rules of models comparison. The article demonstrates a specifically designed table for processing of the results of matrixes subtraction and calculation formulas of standardized weighting coefficients of importance for each index and a complex quality index of maintenance of the assessed systems. It also contains rules of making ratings of systems’ quality. The main positive effect from the application of the proposed method is a considerable decrease of time and resources needed for the quality assessment of systems and a possibility of software realization of a rational processing of information in the process of management of big technical systems’ maintenance.

Full Text:

PDF (Russian)


Duddy C., Piggins A. A foundation for Pareto optimality // Journal of Mathematical Economics. 2020. 88. P. 25-30.

Petchrompo S., Coit D. W., Brintrup A., Wannakrairot A., Kumar Parlikad A. A review of Pareto pruning methods for multi-objective optimization // Computers & Industrial Engineering. 2022. 167. 108022.

Men J., Chen G., Zhou L., Chen P. A pareto-based multi-objective network design approach for mitigating the risk of hazardous materials transportation // Process Safety and Environmental Protection. 2022. 161. 860-875.

Andria J. A computational proposal for a robust estimation of the Pareto tail index: An application to emerging markets // Applied Soft Computing. 2022. 114. 108048.

Azgaldov G., Kostin A. Applied Qualimetry: Its origins, errors and misconceptions // Benchmarking: An International Journal, Volume 18, Number 3, 2011. P. 428-444.

Freund, L., Al-Majeed, S., Millard, A. Towards the Definition of a Strategic Complexity Management Framework for Complex Industrial Systems // 16th International System of Systems Engineering Conference, SoSE 2021. 2021. 9497491, с. 210-215.

Ilic, M., Jaddivada, R. Unified value-based feedback, optimization and risk management in complex electric energy systems // Optimization and Engineering. 2020. 21(2), с. 427-483

Katina, P.F., Pyne, J.C., Keating, C.B., Komljenovic, D. Complex system governance as a framework for asset management // Sustainability (Switzerland). 2021. 13(15),8502

Cox, T., Lowrie, K. Improving Risk Management of Complex Systems // Risk Analysis. 2021. 41(1), с. 1-2.

Vartanyan, A.A. Improving the efficiency of an industrial enterprise due to the architectural approach to a complex information

management system // Research in World Economy. 2020. 11(3), с. 311-319.

Adhikari, S., Chakraborty, S. Random matrix eigenvalue problems in structural dynamics: An iterative approach // Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing. 2021. 164,108260.

Fang, L., Damanik, D., Guo, S. Generic spectral results for CMV matrices with dynamically defined Verblunsky coefficients // Journal of Functional Analysis. 2020. 279(12),108803.

Liu, B., Su, H., Wu, L., Shen, X Controllability for multi-agent systems with matrix-weight-based signed network // Applied Mathematics and Computation. 2021. 411,126520.

Mongia, A., Majumdar, A. Matrix completion on learnt graphs: Application to collaborative filtering // Expert Systems with Applications. 2021. 185,115652.

Kesarwani, A., Pandey, S.K., Sarkar, S., Venkateswarlu, A Recursive MDS matrices over finite commutative rings // Discrete Applied Mathematics. 2021. с. 384-396.

Bilyatdinov K Z Complex methodology of technical systems quality assessment in the process of maintenance 2020 Scientific and technical Volga region bulletin 11 pp 20-23 (in Russian)

Cox, T., Lowrie, K. Improving Risk Management of Complex Systems // Risk Analysis. 2021. 41(1). P. 1-2.

Martins, L.A., Afonso, P., Freire, A.P., Costa, H. Evolution of quality assessment in SPL: A systematic mapping // IET Software. 14(6), 2020. P. 572-581.

Minnullina A., Minnullin R., Kopytova A., Savoskina E. Production strategy development for an energy company based on SADT // E3S Web of Conferences. "International Scientific and Practical Conference "Environmental Risks and Safety in Mechanical Engineering", ERSME 2020", 2020. 07015.

Nski, M.J., Sikorski, T., Kaczorowska, D., (...), Nda, J.S., Janik, P. A case study on power quality in a virtual power plant: long term assessment and global index application // Energies. 2020. 13(24). 6578.

Oluwatobi, A.O., Alli-Johnson, V.A., Ayedun, C.A., Akinjare, O.A. Assessment of the effectiveness of maintenance management systems in delivering quality maintenance services in higher institutions // Journal of Physics: Conference Series. 2019. 1299(1). 012015.

Riahinezhad, M., Masson, J.-F., Collins, P., (...), Lacasse, M.A., Johansen, J. Innovative Construction Products: From Qualification and Performance Assessment to Quality Control // Journal of Architectural Engineering. 2021. 27(3). 04021021.

Calabrese R., Osmetti S.A. A new approach to measure systemic risk: A bivariate copula model for dependent censored data // European Journal of Operational Research. 2019. Vol. 279(3). - Р. 1053-1064.

Gerami J. An interactive procedure to improve estimate of value efficiency in DEA // Expert Systems with Applications. 2019. № 137. - Р. 29-45.

Pačaiová H., Sinay J., Nagyová A. Development of GRAM – A risk measurement tool using risk based thinking principles // Measurement: Journal of the International Measurement Confederation. 2017. № 100. - P. 288-296.

Kalimoldayev M., Abdildayeva A., Mamyrbayev O. Information system based on the mathematical model of the EPS. Open engineering. 2016. Vol. 6. No. 1. Pp. 464-469.

Shafik M.B., Chen H., Rashed G. Planning and reliability assessment to integrate distributed automation system into distribution networks utilizing binary hybrid PSO and GSA algorithms considering uncertainties // International Transactions on Electrical Energy Systems. 2020. Article e12594

Bilyatdinov K.Z., Krivchun Е.А. Development and improvement of assessment means of technical systems quality in the process of maintenance // Proceedings of the 9th International Conference «Distributed Computing and Grid Technologies in Science and Education» (GRID'2021), Dubna, Russia, July 5-9, 2021. Vol. 3041, р. 579-583.

Biliatdinov K.Z., Dosikov V.S., Meniailo V.V. Improvement of the paired comparison method for implementation in computer programs used in assessment of technical systems’ quality // Computer Research and Modeling, 2021, vol. 13, no. 6, pp. 1125-1135.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Abava  Кибербезопасность FRUCT 2023

ISSN: 2307-8162